WebVivant

Another good reason not to use a mobile phone

Cellphones may cause cancer, says a forthcoming report. But that's only one reason not to have one

NEC P3A 10-year investigation into health issues associated with mobile phones - run by the World Health Organisation (WHO) - will end soon, and will conclude that there's an increased risk of cancer with heavy cellphone use.

Which is fine by me, because I gave up using a mobile over a year ago, and hadn't used one much for a couple of years before that. For me, this latest health scare is just one more reason not to have a mobile. And given that I have a healthy cynicism about such reports, it's not even the main reason.

And I'm no Luddite. Really. I had my first cellphone in 1991 - an NEC P3 - and have owned one pretty much constantly since then. But the cellphone really started to annoy me. I hate being interrupted, especially when I'm away from the office. Why should I stop what I'm doing - which is generally something I want or need to do - just because someone, somewhere else has decided that what they have to say is more important? It so rarely is.

As cellphone technology developed, the ways of being interrupted just increased, what with texts and mobile email. And don't get me started on spam texts. I started to switch off the cellphone for longer and longer periods. In the end, it became nothing more than an expensive piece of jewellery.

Without the cellphone, my life is no longer so interrupt-driven. I get a lot more done.

I do miss it a little. I love gadgets. And cellphones are little gems of technology. I just wish they weren't so annoying.

Now I watch and pity cellphone users as they twitch in response to those irritating little dings that mean a text message has arrived. Cellphones have turned an entire generation into Pavlovian puppets, whose strings are pulled by whoever is at the other end of that call or text.

Blackberry users are the most acute cases, of course. I've never met one who doesn't have the Blackberry Twitch - that rapid eye-flicking as they check the screen every few seconds to see if something's arrived; the nervous grimace when there's nothing (which hits a nerve connected directly to their low self-esteem); or the involuntary spasm when there is, and they must waste no time in reading it. Owning a Blackberry is a statement that "I am so important that I must see everything at once." Maybe that message does just say 'see you tonight' or 'LOL': nevertheless, they must know that now.

Sad.

Bad ScienceAs for that health scare … well, we'll see. Naturally, the mobile phone industry likes to point out that lots of studies have found no link between mobile phone use and brain tumours. Of course, many of those studies were sponsored by the mobile phone industry. And if you've read Bad Science by Ben Goldacre (which you really should), you'll know to take such studies with a large handful of salt. Even the WHO report has been criticised for skewing its results in favour of cellphones.

So giving up your cellphone for the sake of your health might be a wise move … or not. Who cares when there are so many other good reasons?

 

Comments (5)

Tags: technology mobile-phones health cellphones science

Please note: comments on this site are moderated - partly to eliminate spamming and partly to avoid wasting space and bandwidth. Any comments deemed offensive, juvenile, stupid or pointless are deleted.

Write a comment

  • Required fields are marked with *.

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code.
Security Code:
 
David Robertson
Posts: 3
Comment
Re: Another good reason not to use a mobile phone
Reply #5 on : Thu October 29, 2009, 09:40:05
The best thing to come from the age of the mobile phone are those very funny Orange adverts at the cinema.
Clive Frost
Posts: 3
Comment
Mobile phones
Reply #4 on : Tue November 03, 2009, 15:10:43
If you don't want to be interrupted, you could....er....just not answer it and pick up any message later from your voice mail.
"Why should I stop what I'm doing just because someone, somewhere else has decided that what they have to say is more important?" No one, however important or unimportant their call to you might be, is stopping you from doing anything - that is entirely your decision and your responsibility. You are the master of your own digit hovering over the green answer button - to answer or not to answer, that is the only question you need to ask yourself!
steve
Posts: 2
Comment
Re: Another good reason not to use a mobile phone
Reply #3 on : Wed November 04, 2009, 01:04:41
@clive - you obviously missed the bit where I said I was switching the phone off for longer and longer periods. That indeed stopped the interruptions: it also rendered the phone pointless. Leaving the phone on but allowing it to go to voicemail would have been equally pointless but with the added irritation of the damn thing ringing.
Clive Frost
Posts: 3
Comment
Mobile phones
Reply #2 on : Thu November 05, 2009, 12:16:32
No, I didn't miss that bit, but thought it as equally illogical as the rest of your 'good' reasons for not using a mobile phone. I quite often don't answer my phone if I am doing something else or talking to someone else and I use my voice mail to listen to any messages later at my own convenience - that's its purpose! My phone also allows me to switch the ringing tone off when I don't want to hear it - doesn't yours? Might I suggest you get an upgrade to a more modern phone? Only teasing!
steve
Posts: 2
Comment
Re: Another good reason not to use a mobile phone
Reply #1 on : Thu November 05, 2009, 12:21:43
> My phone also allows me to switch the ringing tone off when I don't want to hear it - doesn't yours?

I've no idea - it's been so long since I had any reason to use it that I've forgotten how it works. What I've done is simply take the next logical step - switched it off completely and shut down the account. Now it's working perfectly!